The Stories We Invent About Others

Attitudes Shaped by Grace | Day 29

“To answer before listening— that is folly and shame.” (Proverbs 18:13, NIV)

Good morning, dear friends. A text comes in and the screen shows only the first line. Before we open it, we have decided what the rest of the message says, and our thumbs are already moving. Keep that half-read message in mind this morning, because the Lord has a word for us about the stories we finish for other people before they have finished telling them.

The Story We Finish for Them

It happens faster than we can catch it. A family is missing from worship three weeks in a row. A coworker leaves the meeting early without a word. A neighbor pulls into the driveway and walks past us without a wave. A brief conversation at a front door ends a little abruptly. We observe a behavior, and within seconds we have assigned a motive, built a history, and reached a conclusion. Then we react, not to the person, but to the story we wrote about the person. The strange part is that they never said a line of it. We supplied the whole script and then felt hurt, offended, or vindicated by words that only existed in our own heads.

Our invented stories often reveal something about us. We would rather hold a finished story than an open question. A finished story asks nothing of us. An open question might ask us to pick up the phone, cross the street, or stand at a door a little longer, and we have let our own comfort matter more than the neighbor Jesus has placed in front of us. That is the honest shape of the habit, and it was in us before the world ever trained it. The world only gave it good names. A fast read on people is called good instincts. A confident take is called competence. Being the first to say what is really going on is called being sharp. The quickest verdict in the room wins the room.

Scripture does not call it sharp. “To answer before listening— that is folly and shame” (Proverbs 18:13, NIV). Solomon puts the answer and the listening in the wrong order and names what comes of it. A few verses later he describes exactly how a story gets built from one side. “In a lawsuit the first to speak seems right, until someone comes forward and cross-examines” (Proverbs 18:17, NIV). The first account always sounds complete. It sounds complete because nobody has asked it a question yet. When we build a story about someone out of what we saw from the driveway, we are the first to speak, we are the only one speaking, and we are the judge, and no one is going to cross-examine us unless we go and ask.

Even a prophet could get it wrong. Samuel came to the house of Jesse to anoint a king, saw the oldest son, and was certain he was looking at the Lord’s choice. “But the LORD said to Samuel, ‘Do not consider his appearance or his height, for I have rejected him. The LORD does not look at the things people look at. People look at the outward appearance, but the LORD looks at the heart’” (1 Samuel 16:7, NIV). Samuel saw a height and a face and finished the story. God saw a heart. That is the gap every invented story lives in. We can see the behavior. We cannot see the heart, and the heart is where the real story is. Jesus said the same thing to a crowd that had judged him for healing a man on the Sabbath. “Stop judging by mere appearances, but instead judge correctly” (John 7:24, NIV). He did not tell them never to judge. He told them to judge by what was true, and what was true was more than what they had seen.

The One Who Already Knew Ours

Luke tells of a dinner where two stories were written in the same moment. A Pharisee named Simon had invited Jesus to his house. While they were at the table, a woman who had lived a sinful life in that town came in, stood behind Jesus at his feet weeping, wet his feet with her tears, wiped them with her hair, kissed them, and poured perfume on them. “When the Pharisee who had invited him saw this, he said to himself, ‘If this man were a prophet, he would know who is touching him and what kind of woman she is—that she is a sinner’” (Luke 7:39, NIV). In one unspoken sentence Simon finished two stories. He finished hers: a sinner, and nothing more to know. He finished Jesus’ story too: a real prophet would have seen what Simon saw and pulled away. Jesus answered a thought that had never been said out loud. He told Simon of two people forgiven debts they could not repay, asked which would love the lender more, and then pointed to the woman who had not stopped kissing his feet since she came in. Her many sins had been forgiven, he said, and that was why she loved much. Then he spoke to her directly and sent her home forgiven and at peace. Jesus knew exactly who was touching him and what kind of woman she was, far better than Simon did, and he knew what Simon was thinking before Simon moved his lips. The one person at that table who could have judged by what he saw was the one who looked at the heart.

That is the difference between Jesus and us. We invent stories because we do not know the rest, and we cannot bear to leave the page blank. Jesus never invented a story about anyone, because he already knew the rest. He knew it about the woman, he knew it about Simon, and he knows it about us. He knows every unkind assumption we have made about a brother or sister, every motive we assigned without asking, every verdict we reached from across a parking lot. He read the whole message, not the first line. And knowing all of it, he went to the cross and gave his life for the sins of the whole world, ours included, and rose from the dead. We are not forgiven on the strength of a flattering story about ourselves. We are forgiven by a Savior who read the real one and loved us anyway.

That changes what we do with the blank page. Because we have already been fully known and fully forgiven, we no longer need a quick verdict to make us feel safe or right. Our peace with God rests on Jesus, not on being the first one in the room with an answer, so we are free to do the slower thing and learn what is actually true. The Holy Spirit, working in us through that gospel, grows a different first move. The habit he grows is simple to say and takes a lifetime to learn: talk to people, not about them, and do not finish a story God has not told us. It sounds like this: “We have missed you. How have you been?” “Is there anything I can be praying about for you?” Those are not clever techniques. They are what love does when it has been loved first. Asking before concluding does not abandon truth. It makes room for the truth before we decide what is needed, and sometimes what is needed, once we know, is a gentle word of God’s law or a hand to help carry a burden we never guessed was there. Either way we are now answering the real person instead of the one we invented. Jesus Christ knew the rest of our story and still came for us. That is the Savior whose Spirit now teaches us to put down the script and go find out.

Prayer

Heavenly Father, I confess that I am quick to finish other people’s stories. I see a little and decide a lot, and I have treated my guesses about my neighbor as if they were facts. Forgive me for the motives I assigned, the histories I invented, and the hearts I judged from a distance when only you can see a heart. Thank you that Jesus knew the whole of my story and still gave himself for me.

Lord Jesus, thank you for the gift of the Holy Spirit. Make me slow to answer and quick to listen. When someone is missing, or distant, or short with me, let my first move be a question instead of a verdict. Give me the words to ask, the patience to hear the answer, and the love to stay. Be with everyone this morning who is being judged by a story they never told, and bring them the comfort of a Savior who knows them completely. In Jesus’ name I pray. Amen.

Thank you for reading this morning. The next time a message shows you only its first line, let that be a small reminder to open it and read the rest before you answer. In the next devotion we look at the two words that end more conversations than any others, “I’m fine,” and what watchful love does when it hears them.

To God be the glory.

Pray, praise, and give thanks, for God is good and His mercy endures forever.

If you received this message and are not on the daily distribution for them via text or know someone you would like to share these messages with, just have them text “add” to 833-779-8793.